Since launching my most recent book, The Road to Happenstance, I have seen a lot of reviews, both good and not-so-good. Thanks to all those who offered their thoughts and opinions and posted them to the various social media sites. I do appreciate all the effort and time it takes, because I do it for others…often.
Here are 8 tips for writing a book review.
1) Write a catchy headline.
My favourite comes from Eleanor Bertin’s review of Happenstance: “Mitford Meets Narnia.” Love that! In three words, it communicates mood, genre, story world. I admit I have trouble coming up with punchy headlines, but I’ll keep working on it. It’s a hook to draw people into reading the review.
2) Set out pertinent information on the book:
— title (if not already apparent)
— author (if not already apparent)
— genre
— series or stand-alone
3) Compile a brief summary of the book.
Keyword here: brief. The purpose of a review is to draw readers to the book, not to tell them the story in your own words. PLEASE do not include spoilers. 🤐
A spoiler is an element that threatens to spoil the experience for future readers because it reveals too much of the story, thus stealing the tension and the punch line. 😫
Think about it. Would you tell the punch line to a joke, then try to tell the joke? Wrong order. So please DO NOT include background information (the exact reason for the character’s problem), tension points (what brings him to a moment of decision), outcomes (who ends up with whom). Just give us the main character(s), the setting, the beginning action, and perhaps a carefully worded lead into the rest of the story.
4) Include memorable quotes.
This is not essential, but interesting and helpful. If possible, site the page number or location point.
5) Give brief personal praise/critique.
Honest critiques are acceptable. Not everyone will love the book. But be kind. I have reviewed books positively because they include excellent writing, or intriguing characters, or fascinating plotlines, even though I personally don’t “like” the feel of the piece. I want to give others the opportunity to read the story and judge for themselves.
6) Mention similar books.
This helps those reading your review to get a better idea of the kind of book this is. Here I re-mention Eleanor’s “Mitford Meets Narnia” headline. It offers immediate connection.
7) Your recommendation.
You may wish to recommend the book to a particular reader group or age or interest level For example: recommend a historical fiction to history buffs. Mention good research.
8) Stars rating.
Remember that whether or not you personally loved or hated the story, you should choose the star level that confirms the quality of the writing, the interest level of the story. Be fair, be honest, be kind.
So, now you know what’s expected. Practice writing reviews. It’s helpful for authors and also grows your skill as a reviewer.